All posts

Custom software or another subscription? How small businesses can decide

Off-the-shelf tools are often the right answer. Sometimes they aren't. A practical way for small businesses to decide whether to buy, connect or build.

Most small businesses don't set out to build software. They start with a spreadsheet, add a subscription, then another, then a third to fill the gap between the first two. One day someone notices the team spends Friday afternoons copying data between them.

At that point the question comes up: should we keep buying tools, or build something of our own? There's no universal answer, but there is a sensible way to decide.

Start by assuming you should buy

This might sound odd from a company that builds custom software, but off-the-shelf tools are frequently the right call. Accounting, email, payroll, basic CRM, online payments — mature products do these well, cheaply, and with security teams far bigger than any small business could afford. Rebuilding them from scratch rarely makes sense.

So the default should be: if a tool fits most of how you work, use it. The question is what to do when it doesn't.

Three options, not two

People frame this as "buy versus build", but there's a middle path that's often the best value.

OptionWhen it fitsWatch out for
Buy a productIt covers most of your process and you can live with its way of workingPer-seat costs that grow with every hire, and features you pay for but never use
Connect what you haveEach tool is fine on its own; the pain is re-typing data between themIntegrations need looking after when the tools change
Build something customYour process is what makes you different, or nothing fits without heavy workaroundsIt needs an owner, and the up-front cost is higher

Signs you've outgrown off-the-shelf

You'll usually recognise a few of these before anyone says "custom software" out loud:

  • The same customer details get typed into two or three systems.
  • A spreadsheet is emailed around and nobody is sure which copy is current.
  • Critical work runs on an old Access or FileMaker database that one person understands.
  • Your subscription bill grows every time you hire, but most staff use a fraction of the features.
  • The team has a list of workarounds, and new starters have to be taught them.
  • You can't get the report you actually run the business on without an afternoon in Excel.

One or two of these is normal. Four or more usually means the tools are shaping the business, rather than the other way around.

Try connecting before you replace

If the pain is mostly double entry, start there. A well-built integration — for example, jobs flowing from your booking system into Xero as invoices — can remove most of the friction for a fraction of the cost of a new system. It's also reversible: if you later decide to build, the integration work usually isn't wasted.

We often recommend this first, because it's the cheapest way to find out whether the problem is the tools themselves or just the gaps between them.

When building is the better deal

Custom software earns its keep when:

  • Your process is the product. The way you schedule, quote or deliver is what sets you apart, and generic tools would flatten it.
  • Several tools are doing one job badly. One system with one set of records replaces the patchwork and ends the re-typing.
  • The workaround cost is real. Hours spent every week on copying, checking and fixing add up quickly.
  • You want to own it. No per-seat fees, no vendor roadmap deciding your features, and code you can take to any developer.

Kaladi Kitchens is a good example of the last two. Members needed to book shared commercial kitchens across several sites and record the state of each kitchen at every hand-over — a combination no single off-the-shelf product handled well. The result was one booking platform with photo-backed checklists. Bugaboo Landscaping had a similar story across a franchise network, ending in a single system for bookings and before-and-after photos.

A fair way to compare costs

Comparing a subscription to a build isn't just sticker price against sticker price. Over a few years, write down:

  1. Subscriptions: monthly fees multiplied by seats, including the growth you expect.
  2. Hidden labour: hours per week spent re-keying, reconciling and working around gaps, multiplied by what that time costs you.
  3. Build: the fixed price of the build, plus hosting and an optional support retainer.
  4. Risk: what happens if a vendor raises prices, drops a feature or shuts down — or if the one person who understands your spreadsheet leaves.

Sometimes the numbers say "keep buying". That's a perfectly good outcome. We'd rather tell you that than build something you don't need.

How we approach it

When a business asks us about business software, the first step is mapping how a job actually moves — from first enquiry to paid invoice — and finding where time and data leak out. Then we recommend buy, connect or build for each gap, with the reasoning written down. If building is the answer, it happens in fixed-scope sprints, with a working version you can try within weeks, running alongside your old tools until the team trusts it.

Common questions

Is custom software only for big companies?

No. Smaller teams often feel the pain of bad-fitting tools more, because every wasted hour comes out of a small pool. The key is starting with the smallest system that removes the biggest pain, not a grand platform.

Can custom software work with Xero and our other tools?

Yes. Integrating with the tools you keep — Xero, HubSpot, Google Workspace and others — is a normal part of a build, so you don't have to replace everything at once.

What happens if our needs change later?

Because you own the code, it can change with you: add a module, adjust a process, or hand it to another developer. That flexibility is one of the main reasons to build rather than rent.

How do we know which option is right for us?

Start with a conversation about where the time goes. If several problems overlap, a workflow gap analysis maps them properly and gives you a buy, connect or build recommendation for each. Get in touch to start.

Want this looked at for your business?

A short call, no pitch. Tell us how things run today and we'll tell you honestly what's worth doing first.